Lindsay Lohan reportedly raised a screaming ruckus at a New York City hotel Monday night, seemingly over a conflict with rumored flame Calum Best -- though reports on exactly what happened differ. THE NY POST's PAGE SIX claims that Lohan and Best got into a "screaming match" at the Soho Grand that started in the penthouse and ended up in the lobby. "Calum's clothes were torn, and after a few minutes, they got back into the elevator and went back to their room," reportedly said one onlooker. THE NY DAILY NEWS' RUSH & MOLLOY have a different take, reporting that Lindsay returned to the hotel with friends (Best not among them) and "was screaming about how Calum was cheating on her," claims a source. According to their report, Lohan and Best have been staying in separate suites, and Lohan was "gently escorted to her suite" by hotel management when guests complained about the screaming. Both reports say that Lindsay and Calum were at Stereo together the following night, and both claim that friends of Lohan do not approve of Best and his treatment of Lindsay. A rep for Lohan had no comment when contacted by PAGE SIX, but Lindsay had a comment of her own for Access' Dish of Salt correspondent Laura Saltman last night. When asked about her busy week traveling between The Bahamas and New York, Lindsay replied that she'd been in New York for a while, adding, "Don't you read the New York Post?"